best air fryer america's test kitchen

America's Test Kitchen's Best Air Fryer: Top Picks 2023

By Rachel Williams
AD

In the pursuit of healthier cooking methods, air fryers have risen to prominence, and America's Test Kitchen (ATK), known for its rigorous product testing, has weighed in on the best models. With their commitment to quality and performance, ATK's recommendations can guide your search for the perfect air fryer.

ATK has put numerous air fryers through their paces, considering factors like capacity, features, ease of use, and, most importantly, how well they cook food. Their top picks balance these aspects to bring you the best air fryers currently on the market.

Top Air Fryers According to ATK

Here are the three air fryers that impressed ATK the most, each offering a unique set of features and performance.

AD
6 Best Air Fryers of 2026, Tested and Reviewed
6 Best Air Fryers of 2026, Tested and Reviewed
A Case for Buying an Air Fryer (and What You Need To Make the Most of It) | America's Test Kitchen
A Case for Buying an Air Fryer (and What You Need To Make the Most of It) | America's Test Kitchen
Top 5 Air Fryers Every Kitchen Needs | Recipes From A Pantry
Top 5 Air Fryers Every Kitchen Needs | Recipes From A Pantry

Before delving into the details, it's essential to understand that ATK's top picks span different price points and capacities, catering to various needs and preferences.

Cosori Air Fryer Max XL

The Cosori Air Fryer Max XL earned the title of ATK's Editors' Choice for its exceptional performance, user-friendly design, and competitive price. Its 5.8-quart capacity is generous enough to handle meals for up to three people.

The Best Air Fryers of 2026, Tested by the Taste of Home Kitchen
The Best Air Fryers of 2026, Tested by the Taste of Home Kitchen
I Put 10 Air Fryers to the Test — Only 3 Impressed Me
I Put 10 Air Fryers to the Test — Only 3 Impressed Me
an orange frisbee cooker with the lid open
an orange frisbee cooker with the lid open

Cosori's wide temperature range (up to 450°F) and 11 presets allow for versatile cooking, from roasting and baking to dehydration and reheating. Its non-stick basket is easy to clean, and the air fryer comes with a helpful recipe booklet to get you started.

Ninja AP303AMZSS Max XL Air Fryer

For those willing to invest in a premium air fryer, the Ninja Max XL impressed ATK with its powerful performance and innovative features. Its 5.5-quart capacity is sufficient for serving 3-5 people.

AD

What sets the Ninja apart is its 6-quart crisper basket that fits beautifully on the counter, and the unit's robust 1550-watt heating element, ensuring lightning-fast cooking. Additionally, its unique Max Crisp Technology delivers exceptionally crispy results without the need for excessive oil.

Best Air Fryers
Best Air Fryers
The Best Air Fryer and Pan Roasted Chicken Wings | Full Episode | America's Test Kitchen (S23 E12)
The Best Air Fryer and Pan Roasted Chicken Wings | Full Episode | America's Test Kitchen (S23 E12)
BEST AIR FRYERS ON AMAZON
BEST AIR FRYERS ON AMAZON
the best air fryers for every kitchen, from appliance to food processor
the best air fryers for every kitchen, from appliance to food processor
two hamburgers cooking in an open toaster oven with trays full of food
two hamburgers cooking in an open toaster oven with trays full of food
5 best air fryers
5 best air fryers

내밀 Oster Digital Air Fryer XL

If you're looking for a large capacity air fryer at a lower price point, the Oster Digital Air Fryer XL is an attractive option. With its 6.6-quart capacity, it can accommodate family-sized meals or cook enough for leftovers.

Although it's less feature-packed than our top picks, the Oster offers commendable performance, with a 1500-watt heating element and a user-friendly digital interface. Its circulating heat technology ensures even and consistent cooking results.

AD

What to Consider When Buying an Air Fryer

When choosing an air fryer, consider the following factors to find the perfect fit for your needs and preferences.

7 Best Air Fryers of 2025 – Make Every Meal Crispy & Delicious!
7 Best Air Fryers of 2025 – Make Every Meal Crispy & Delicious!

Capacity: How many people will you typically be cooking for? Air fryer capacities range from 2 to 11 quarts, with most models falling between 3 and 6 quarts.

Features and Presets

Air fryers with multiple presets and adjustable temperature settings offer more versatility in cooking. While advanced features like digital interfaces and smart آسيا ωνle connectivity can enhance your experience, they may not be essential for everyone.

AD

Ease of Use and Cleanup

A user-friendly control panel and non-stick, dishwasher-safe parts contribute to an enjoyable cooking experience and effortless cleanup. Consider these aspects when comparing air fryer models.

Ultimately, the most important factor when choosing an air fryer is its cooking performance. By trusting ATK's rigorous testing, you can confidently select a model that will meet your expectations and help you enjoy healthier, delicious meals at home. Happy cooking!"

AD