accompagnatur request THE most natural-looking mascaras: 2023's best
In the quest for beautiful, voluminous lashes, many women turn to mascara to achieve a dramatic look. However, not everyone wants a serious dose of drama. For those who prefer a more subtle, natural effect, browsing the countless mascara options can be overwhelming. To make your search easier, we've compiled a list of the best natural-looking mascaras that offer buildable volume, definition, and length without the harsh, "I'm wearing mascara" effect.
Before delving into our top picks, it's essential to understand what makes a mascara natural-looking. This involves looking for formulas that provide just the right amount of pigment, separation, and curl to define your lashes without clumping or becoming too noticeable. A natural-looking mascara should also be smudge-resistant and long-wearing, ensuring that your lashes stay in place and looking great from morning till night.
Top Natural-Looking Mascaras
The market abounds with mascaras claiming to provide a natural look, but not all live up to their promises. To help narrow down your options, we've selected five exemplary products that consistently receive rave reviews for providing a natural yet noticeable effect:



L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise
The L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise mascara has gained a cult following due to its ability to create dramatically full lashes without looking over-the-top. Its unique brush features over 200 bristles designed to coat each lash from root to tip, delivering impressive volume and length without clumping. The formula is infused with cinnamon and Murumuru butter to nourish and condition the lashes, resulting in a natural, healthy look.
To achieve a natural yet defined look, apply one or two coats of L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise, focusing on the roots for the most lift and separating the lashes as you go. This mascara is available in various shades, including black, brown, and bronze, allowing you to choose the one that best suits your preferences and skin tone.



Marc Jacobs Beauty Velvet Noir Major Volume Mascara
Marc Jacobs Beauty Velvet Noir Major Volume Mascara is a luxury product that offers a stunning, yet natural-looking effect. Its unique concave brush ais designed to scoop up excess formula, preventing clumping and promoting an even coat on each lash. The rich, creamy formula features shell powder and safflower extract, providing long-lasting, smudge-resistant volume and definition.
For a natural yet noticeable look, apply one coat of Marc Jacobs Beauty Velvet Noir Major Volume Mascara, focusing on the roots and separating the lashes with the tip of the brush. This mascara comes in a sleek, rose-gold packaging and is available in black and brown shades.
The Science Behind Natural-Looking Mascaras
To create a mascara that appears natural while still providing noticeable definition, manufacturers use specific formulations and brush designs. Understanding the science behind these products can help you make an informed decision when choosing the right one for your lashes.






Formula composition
Natural-looking mascaras typically have a lighter, thinner consistency that doesn't weigh down the lashes. These formulas often include conditioning ingredients such as waxes, oils, and extracts to nourish and strengthen the lashes. They may also contain powders and pigments that provide just the right amount of color payoff without looking too stark or heavy.
Some mascaras, like the L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise, incorporate natural extracts and botanical ingredients to enhance the appearance of lashes. For example, Murumuru butter is known for its high fatty acid and vitamin content, which can help condition and moisturize lashes, while cinnamon is believed to stimulate blood flow and promote lash growth.
Brush design and bristle type
The brush plays a crucial role in determining the mascara's application and final effect. Natural-looking mascaras typically feature smaller, more sparsely packed bristles designed to separate and define the lashes without clumping. Some brushes may also have unique shapes or concavities meant to capture excess formula, preventing unwanted clumps and ensuring an even coat.

For instance, the Marc Jacobs Beauty Velvet Noir Major Volume Mascara features a concave brush that scoops up and controls the formula, ensuring that only the right amount is deposited onto the lashes. This design helps to minimize clumping and delivers a more natural, even finish.
Fiber structures
In recent years, advancements in mascara technology have led to the development of innovative fiber structures that can transform the appearance of lashes. Products like the L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise use a combination of natural fibers and synthetic waxes to create a lightweight, comfortable formula that adheres to lashes, providing noticeable volume and length without feeling heavy or stiff.
These fiber structures can help create the appearance of thicker, more luxurious lashes, imparting a natural-looking boost that's subtler than traditional, heavy-duty mascaras.
Pigment concentration
The concentration of pigments in a mascara formula directly impacts the final color payoff. Natural-looking mascaras typically feature a lower pigment concentration, providing just enough color to define and darken the lashes without looking too intense or dramatic.
A lower pigment concentration is particularly useful for those with lighter hair or who prefer a more subtle, natural effect. By opting for a mascara with a lighter pigment load, you can still achieve defined lashes without the harsh, overpowering look of a heavily pigmented formula.
Ultimately, finding the perfect natural-looking mascara is a highly personal journey that depends on your lash type, preferences, and desired effect. By experimenting with different brands, formulas, and brush designs, you're sure to discover a mascara that enhances your lashes' natural beauty while providing the definition and length you desire. So go ahead and explore the world of natural-looking mascaras – your perfect, subtle staple might be just a few swipes away!





