Best Toaster Ovens: Consumer Reports Top Picks
In the quest for the perfect kitchen appliance, toaster ovens often get overlooked, yet they're versatile and energy-efficient powerhouses. This guide explores the best toaster ovens, based on recent Consumer Reports, to help you find your ideal kitchen companion.
Consumer Reports' thorough testing and reviews simplify the purchasing process, ensuring you make an informed decision. Let's delve into the best toaster ovens that excel in practicality, capacity, and performance.
Size and Capacity
Toaster ovens come in various sizes, accommodating different needs and counter space. When choosing, consider the size of your family and the types of food you'll be preparing.



Compact toaster ovens are great for small apartments or light use, while large capacity models can take on full-sized pizzas and roasts. Consumer Reports suggests opting for a toaster oven with a suitable interior volume for your needs.
Compact Toaster Ovens
Small in size yet mighty in performance, compact toaster ovens offer convenience without taking up much counter space. The Breville Smart Oven TOB-1450 and Cuisinart TOB-260N1 are CR topscores for their size, boasting even heating and user-friendly interfaces.



Both models can fit four slices of bread or a 9x13-inch baking dish. Despite their smaller size, they still provide significant cooking versatility.
Large-Capacity Toaster Ovens
If you're looking for a spacious toaster oven, consider the Frigidaire Professional FGOV3072UF and the Hamilton Beach Countertop Oven with Convection (31127). These models can handle full-sized pizzas and have enough room for larger casseroles.
The Frigidaire offers three heating elements and a large door for easy access, while the Hamilton Beach features convection cooking for faster and more even results. Both received high marks from Consumer Reports for their capacity and performance.






Convection vs. Non-Convection
Convection toaster ovens use a fan to circulate hot air, speeding up cooking time and promoting even heat distribution. Non-convection models, on the other hand, rely solely on heating elements for cooking.
Consumer Reports advises that convection toaster ovens typically offer better performance and speed, but they're also more expensive. If budget is a concern, a non-convection model might be a suitable alternative.
Top Convection Toaster Ovens
If you're ready to invest in a convection toaster oven, the Wolf BOV900 and the Breville BOV900XLS boast impressive results. Both ovens received high marks from Consumer Reports for their even heating, speed, and overall cooking performance.

With their robust features, such as smart programming, wide temperature ranges, and spacious interiors, these convection toaster ovens are ideal for serious home cooks who prioritize versatility and efficiency.
Top Non-Convection Toaster Ovens
For those looking for a more affordable option without sacrificing performance, the Black+Decker TO1313SBD and the Cuisinart TOB-195 are worthy contenders. Both non-convection toaster ovens received high ratings from Consumer Reports for their even heat distribution and user-friendly features.
The Black+Decker model offers a digital display and multiple setting options, while the Cuisinart boasts a large interior and a contemporary design. Both provide exceptional value for their price point.
When browsing toaster ovens, keep in mind the size, capacity, and convection or non-convection features that best suit your kitchen and cooking needs. With Consumer Reports' guidance, you're sure to find a toaster oven that serves you well in the years ahead.



