Elizabeth Smart's Kidnapper Convicted: Inside Brian David Mitchell's Life in Prison
In 2002, the nation was captivated by the story of Elizabeth Smart, a 14-year-old girl who was abducted from her Salt Lake City home. The case grabbed headlines and sparked fear among parents across the country. Among the central figures in this haunting tale was Brian David Mitchell, the man arrested and convicted for Elizabeth's kidnapping and sexual assault. This article explores the life, crimes, and fate of Elizabeth Smart's kidnapper, Brian David Mitchell.
Born in 1956, Brian David Mitchell was raised in a devout Mormon family in Salt Lake City. Despite his religious upbringing, Mitchell had a troubled childhood marked by mental health issues and substance abuse. He met Wanda Barzee, his future wife and co-conspirator, in the late 1980s. Together, they embarked on a life of crime and religious fixation, eventually leading to their horrendous crime against Elizabeth Smart.
Brian David Mitchell's Crimes and Motivation
On the night of June 5, 2002, Mitchell snuck into the Smart family's home, armed with a knife, and took Elizabeth at knifepoint. He held her captive for nine months, subjecting her to repeated sexual assault, and dismantling her sense of reality with his twisted religious beliefs. Mitchell claimed to be a prophet and told Elizabeth she was his spiritual wife, part of a polygamous marriage genuinely believed by both Mitchell and Barzee.



Mitchell's crimes were fuelled by his delusions, enhanced by substance abuse, and enabled by his wife, Wanda Barzee. They believed God had commanded Mitchell to take Elizabeth as his wife. During the nine months of her captivity, Elizabeth was forced to participate in Mitchell and Barzee's bizarre rituals and recite prayers. She eventually escaped with the help of local residents, who recognized her from publicity posters.
Arrest and Trial
In 2003, following Elizabeth's escape, Mitchell and Barzee were arrested. Mitchell was charged with kidnapping and sexual assault. The case against him hinged on Elizabeth's testimony, as well as DNA evidence collected from the crime scene. Mitchell maintained his innocence, claiming to be a prophet following God's commands. However, the jury found him guilty in 2011.



The trial exposed the devastation Mitchell had caused. His attorneys tried to use his mental illness as a defense, but ultimately, the jury found him competent to stand trial and guilty on both counts.
Sentencing and Appeal
In 2011, Mitchell was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Mitchell attempted to appeal, claiming his trial lawyer was ineffective and introducing new evidence, including a letter from Barzee expressing her belief in and support of Mitchell's actions. However, these appeals were denied, and Mitchell remains incarcerated at the Federal Medical Center, Butner in North Carolina.
Barzee, who corroborated Elizabeth's account of events, was initially sentenced to 15 years in prison. However, in 2018, she was unexpectedly released from prison to a halfway house, sparking public outcry and protests. She remains under intensive supervision and is set to be released from the residential reentry center in 2021.






Elizabeth Smart's Advocacy and Mitchell's Impact
Despite her ordeal, Elizabeth Smart has become an advocate for child abduction prevention and shared experience programs. She founded the Elizabeth Smart Foundation, dedicated to assisting families and communities impacted by abduction and sexual assault. Smart has also written books, including "My Story," and shared her experiences to help others and promote healing.
Through education, prevention strategies, and advocacy, Smart and her foundation work to empower individuals and communities to stay safer and better cope with abduction and assault. While Mitchell remains in prison, Smart's advocacy ensures his horrendous actions continue to drive positive change, preventing similar crimes and supporting victims.
Elizabeth Smart's kidnapper, Brian David Mitchell, will spend the rest of his life in prison. His actions irreparably changed the course of many lives, but they also catalyzed a nationwide movement for child abduction prevention and victim advocacy. Today, Mitchell's name serves as a somber reminder of the power of community and the importance of preventive measures to keep our children safe.





