How to Build a Commander Deck: Reddit's Best Tips & Strategies
Embarking on the thrilling journey of creating a Commander deck on Reddit involves a blend of strategy, creativity, and a dash of community spirit. This comprehensive guide walks you through the process, from understanding the basics to bolstering your deck's performance and engaging with the vibrant Commander community on Reddit.
Commander, also known as EDH (Elder Dragon Highlander), is a Magic: The Gathering format that emphasizes intricate strategy, formidable creatures, and powerful spells. Building a Commander deck on Reddit not only allows you to showcase your unique style but also presents opportunities to connect with fellow enthusiasts and improve your gameplay.
Navigating Reddit for Commander Content
Reddit serves as a goldmine of information and inspiration for Commander players. Familiarizing yourself with popular subreddits is the first step in leveraging this resource.



Key subreddits for Commander include:
- /r/EDH: The largest and most active Commander subreddit, featuring deck-building discussions, tips, and news.
- /r/EDHDeckbuilding: Dedicated to helping players build and refine their Commander decks, with a focus on constructive feedback.
- /r/EDHRecipes: A subreddit centered around creating and sharing budget-friendly Commander decks.
Searching and Sorting Reddit
Leverage Reddit's search function to find threads, discussions, and decks related to your interests. Use keywords like "Commander," "EDH," and specific commander names to filter relevant results.



Sorting posts by 'top' or 'new' can help you discover the most popular and recent content. Filtering by 'discussion' and 'self' can also unveil hidden gems and personal experiences from fellow players.
Understanding Commander Fundamentals
Before diving into deck-building, grasp the fundamental rules and principles of Commander:
- A deck comprises 100 cards, including one single commander.
- Deck construction follows the general rule that you must have at least 35% lands (64 cards), with the remaining 36 cards being a combination of creatures, instants, sorceries, artifacts, enchantments, and planeswalkers.
- The Commander tax: A four-cost tax on casting spells and playing lands from the command zone.
Themes, power levels, and playstyles vary greatly in Commander, encouraging diverse deck-building and making the format accessible to a wide range of players.






Crafting Your Commander Deck: Step-by-Step
Building an engaging Commander deck involves careful planning and balancing. This section guides you through the process, from choosing a commander to playtesting and refining your deck.
Selecting a Commander
Choosing a commander is the first and most crucial step in creating your deck. Consider your playstyle, budget, and the story you want to tell with your deck. Some popular Commander options include:
- Value-based commanders, like Talrand, Sky Summoner and Estrid, the Mimic, that focus on drawing cards and casting spells.
- xfensive commanders, such as Atraxa, Praetors' Voice and Breya, Etherium Sage, which aim to overwhelm opponents with powerful attacks or board Presence.
- Combative commanders, like Ezuri, Renegade Leader and Yisan, the Wanderer, that equip creatures and utilize powerful synergies.
Deck-Building Strategies
Design your deck around your chosen commander's strengths and weaknesses. Prioritize ramping into your commander's casting cost, and ensure your deck contains enough interaction and removal spells to protect your board state and disrupt opponents.

Include a mix of low-cost and high-impact cards to maintain balance. Consider your deck's power level relative to other decks in your playgroup, and strive for a balance of offense, defense, and resilience.
Engaging with the Commander Community on Reddit
Reddit offers ample opportunities to connect with fellow Commander enthusiasts, gather feedback, and improve your deck-building skills.
Sharing and Receiving Feedback
Post your Commander decklist in relevant subreddits, such as /r/EDH or /r/EDHDeckbuilding, and encourage users to provide constructive criticism. Be open to feedback and willing to make changes based on the input you receive.
Offering feedback to others is also an excellent way to learn and grow as a deck-builder. Critique decks with an eye for balance, synergy, and fun, remembering that everyone's mileage may vary when it comes to personal play preferences.
Participating in Deck-Building Challenges and Collabs
Engage in Commander-related activities and events hosted on Reddit, like deck-building challenges or collabs. These experiences help refine your deck-building skills and introduce you to new ideas and communities.
Some popular events include:
- The woolly mammoth challenge: Building a Commander deck featuring a land base composed of only snow-covered lands.
- Secret Santa EDH: Exchanging Commander decks with a partner from another country for the holidays.
Building a Commander deck on Reddit is an ongoing journey, filled with discovery, growth, and camaraderie. Embrace the process, engage with the community, and above all, have fun interpreting the vast realm of Magic: The Gathering strategy and creativity.
As you delve into the expansive world of Commander, remember that every deck is a work in progress, and every playgroup offers unique experiences. Keep refining your deck, seeking inspiration from fellow players, and nurturing a spirit of good sportsmanship. The Reddit Commander community awaits, ready to welcome you and help you craft something truly extraordinary.
Now, what's on your commander radar? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below, and let's celebrate the wonder of Commander together!





