is wine before liquor never sicker true

Wine Before Liquor: Is the 'Never Sicker' Adage True?

By Mark Rodriguez
AD

You've probably heard the old adage, "Beer before liquor, never been sicker; liquor before beer, never fear." But is this rhyme really a reliable guide to navigating your drinking habits, or is it just an old wives' tale? Let's dive into the science behind this popular phrase to find out if 'wine before liquor, never sicker' holds true.

In the vast expanse of the internet, you'll find countless opinions on this topic. Some swear by the rule, while others dismiss it as mere folklore. But let's approach this from a scientific angle, looking at how your body processes different types of alcohol and how the order you consume them might affect you.

The Science Behind the Drinking Order

At the heart of this debate lies a simple question: Does the order in which you consume alcoholic beverages genuinely impact how you feel the next day?

AD
Funny Drinks/Happy Hour Memes & Ecards - Page 1 | Someecards
Funny Drinks/Happy Hour Memes & Ecards - Page 1 | Someecards
a woman holding a glass of wine in front of a bar with the caption prohibition banned alcohol in 1920
a woman holding a glass of wine in front of a bar with the caption prohibition banned alcohol in 1920
there is a sign in the window that says alcohol is not in my vodkabaar
there is a sign in the window that says alcohol is not in my vodkabaar

Introduced in 1975, the adage suggests that drinking light beverages (beer) before harder ones (liquor) will result in a worse hangover. Conversely, starting with harder drinks would somehow protect you. But is there any scientific evidence to support this claim?

Absorption and Elimination of Alcohol

The key to understanding alcohol's effect on your body lies in its metabolism. Once consumed, alcohol is absorbed into your bloodstream at a constant rate, regardless of the beverage's type. Your liver then breaks down the alcohol, which is then eliminated from your body through urine, sweat, and breath.

a woman pouring red wine into a glass with a rose on the table next to her
a woman pouring red wine into a glass with a rose on the table next to her
three bottles of wine with the words honest wine labels that have no time for your crap
three bottles of wine with the words honest wine labels that have no time for your crap
A Day Without Wine Is Like Just Kidding I Have No Idea Sticker
A Day Without Wine Is Like Just Kidding I Have No Idea Sticker

This process happens at a consistent rate—about one standard drink per hour. So, if you're consuming multiple drinks (apples to apples, i.e., the same type of alcohol, like wine to wine or liquor to liquor), the order likely doesn't make a significant difference.

Hangover Symptoms: The Role of Congeners

Congeners are compounds produced during fermentation that contribute to a beverage's unique taste and color. Some studies suggest that these compounds might be responsible for the severity of hangover symptoms. For instance, wine has more congeners than beer, which might explain why some people feel worse after drinking wine.

AD

However, congeners aren't solely responsible for hangovers. Alcohol's primary ingredient, ethanol, is the main culprit. Excessive consumption of any type of alcohol can lead to a hangover, regardless of the order you drank it in.

a bottle of wine being poured into a glass with the words, the pour still matters alcohol removal ritual
a bottle of wine being poured into a glass with the words, the pour still matters alcohol removal ritual
a bottle of wine next to a table with grapes and other food items on it
a bottle of wine next to a table with grapes and other food items on it
a sign that says life is too short to drink bad wine
a sign that says life is too short to drink bad wine
wine bottles are stacked on top of each other with the words kinda chic to drink sugar free wine and save the sweets for dessert
wine bottles are stacked on top of each other with the words kinda chic to drink sugar free wine and save the sweets for dessert
That's the only stress we need in our lives!
That's the only stress we need in our lives!
Wine Lovers
Wine Lovers

Factors That Truly Affect Your Hangover

Having addressed the popular 'beer before liquor' myth, let's explore factors that genuinely influence your hangover experience.

The most critical factor is the total amount of alcohol consumed. The more you drink, the more likely you are to experience a hangover, regardless of the beverages' order. Other significant factors include:

AD
  • Hydration: Alcohol is a diuretic, meaning it increases urine production. Staying hydrated can mitigate some hangover symptoms.
  • Sleep: Alcohol disrupts your sleep cycles. Aim for a good night's rest to minimize hangover symptoms.
  • Individual Tolerance: People metabolize alcohol differently. Some may experience hangovers more easily than others.

While there's no one-size-fits-all solution to preventing hangovers, Kepler et al. (2019) found that having at least one non-alcoholic drink per hour and maintaining a reasonable alcohol-to-water ratio can help minimize their severity.

Funny Weekend Memes & Ecards - Page 1 | Someecards
Funny Weekend Memes & Ecards - Page 1 | Someecards

So, should you follow the 'wine before liquor, never sicker' adage? While there's no empirical evidence supporting this saying, prioritizing overall responsible drinking habits is always a smart move. Cheers to making informed decisions!

AD