monkey tail cactus vs rat tail cactus

Monkey Tail vs Rat Tail Cactus: Which is Right for Your Collection

By Joseph White
AD

Discovering the perfect succulent for your space can be an exciting journey. Two popular and often compared cacti are the Monkey Tail Cactus and the Rat Tail Cactus. Despite their similar appearance, each has distinct characteristics that set them apart. Let's dive into a detailed comparison of these two charming cacti.

Before we explore the differences, let's briefly discuss their similarities. Both are trailing, non-toxic succulents with long, thin stems and small scale-like leaves. They are also relatively easy to care for, making them popular choices for both experienced and novice plant parents.

The Monkey Tail Cactus (Schlumbergera trunci)

The Monkey Tail Cactus, also known as the Christmas Cactus, is a fascinating plant with a unique growth habit. Its stems grow horizontally and branch out in a zigzag pattern, resembling a monkey's tail, hence its common name.

AD
Monkey Tail Cactus
Monkey Tail Cactus
Monkeytail cactus
Monkeytail cactus
Monkey Tail Cactus Care and Growing Tips
Monkey Tail Cactus Care and Growing Tips

Natively found in Brazil's coastal mountains, the Monkey Tail Cactus thrives in temperatures between 50-80°F (10-27°C) during the day and a 10°F (5°C) drop at night. This temperature differential triggers its stunning display of tubular, segmented flowers in winter, giving it its other common name.

Light Requirements

Monkey Tail Cacti prefer bright, indirect light. Avoid direct sunlight, as it can scorch their leaves. In lower light conditions, they may become less colorful and grow more slowly.

Rat tail or monkey tail?
Rat tail or monkey tail?
some plants hanging from the ceiling in a room
some plants hanging from the ceiling in a room
Monkey Tail Cactus (Hildewintera colademononis)
Monkey Tail Cactus (Hildewintera colademononis)

To encourage better flowering, provide them with a 12-hour light and 12-hour dark cycle during the fall and winter months. This can be achieved by using a grow lamp or covering the plant during the day.

Watering and Soil

Monkey Tail Cacti don't like to dry out completely, so allow the soil to dry out slightly between waterings. They prefer well-draining soil with a pH between 6.0 and 7.0. A potting mix consisting of equal parts peat moss and sand or perlite works well.

AD

During the dormant period, reduce watering to almost none, keeping the soil barely moist. However, ensure they don't sit in waterlogged soil to prevent root rot.

My lovely rat tail cactus in bloom💖
My lovely rat tail cactus in bloom💖
Monkey Tail Cactus Plant Live in 2" Pot, Live Monkey Tail Cactus Houseplant Succulents, 3-5 Inches Tall
Monkey Tail Cactus Plant Live in 2" Pot, Live Monkey Tail Cactus Houseplant Succulents, 3-5 Inches Tall
a man holding up a large cactus plant with pink flowers on it's tail
a man holding up a large cactus plant with pink flowers on it's tail
Free Monkey Tail Cactus Care & Plant Growing Guide
Free Monkey Tail Cactus Care & Plant Growing Guide
My monkey tail is looking stunning at the moment!
My monkey tail is looking stunning at the moment!
Monkey tail cactus
Monkey tail cactus

The Rat Tail Cactus (Disocactus rotundifolius)

The Rat Tail Cactus, also known as the Stonecrop, is a hybrid plant native to tropical Central and South America. It's characterized by its long, trailing stems that grow up to 10 feet (3 meters) with attractive, rounded, green leaves.

Unlike the Monkey Tail Cactus, the Rat Tail Cactus can tolerate a wider range of temperatures, from 60-75°F (15-24°C) during the day, with a 10°F (5°C) drop at night. In optimal conditions, it will produce bell-shaped, fragrant flowers in clusters at the end of its stems.

AD

Light Requirements

Rat Tail Cacti prefer bright, indirect light, similar to the Monkey Tail Cactus. However, they can tolerate lower light levels, making them suitable for indoor environments away from windows.

Monkey Tail Cactus Hanging Plant Rare Fuzzy Trailing Succulent Gift - Etsy
Monkey Tail Cactus Hanging Plant Rare Fuzzy Trailing Succulent Gift - Etsy

Direct sunlight should be avoided, especially during peak daytime hours, as it can cause sunburn. In the wild, Rat Tail Cacti often grow in shaded, partially wooded areas, so they tend to prefer bright, indirect light.

Watering and Soil

Rat Tail Cacti have a higher water tolerance than Monkey Tail Cacti. Allow the top inch of the soil to dry out between waterings. They prefer well-draining soil with a pH between 6.0 and 7.5. A general-purpose potting mix with added perlite or sand works well.

AD

Reduced watering during the winter months is beneficial, but ensure the soil doesn't remain waterlogged. Rat Tail Cacti are quite forgiving if you forget to water them occasionally.

Whether you choose the Monkey Tail Cactus for its unique growth pattern and winter blooms, or the Rat Tail Cactus for its hardiness and low maintenance, both will reward you with their charm and ease of care. So, why not add one of these delightful cacti to your collection today?

AD