should floor joists be pressure treated reddit

Should Floor Joists Be Pressure Treated: The Reddit Debate

By Emily Lee
AD

You might have found yourself contemplating the necessity of pressure treating floor joists after stumbling upon the topic on Reddit. The internet is rife with differing opinions, leaving homeowners, contractors, and DIY enthusiasts wondering: Should floor joists be pressure treated? This article aims to clarify the debate, exploring the benefits, considerations, and industry standards surrounding this topic.

Before delving into the specifics, let's establish a baseline of understanding. Floor joists are horizontally oriented supports that rest on the outer walls of a house or on a foundation. They form the skeleton of your floor, supporting the vast majority of the weight passing through them. Given their integral role, the decision to pressure treat these critical elements deserves careful consideration.

Understanding Pressure Treatment

Pressure treating involves immersing wood in a preservative solution that penetrates deep into the grain. This process imparts significant durability and resistance to various threats, including rot, decay, and termite infestation. Understanding what pressure treatment does and doesn't do is the first step in determining whether it's necessary for floor joists.

AD
How to Strengthen Floor Joists From Beneath
How to Strengthen Floor Joists From Beneath
a wooden bench with the words how far should joist be from the ground?
a wooden bench with the words how far should joist be from the ground?
Floor Joist Blocking and Bridging (Bracing): Complete Guide
Floor Joist Blocking and Bridging (Bracing): Complete Guide

The American Wood Protection Association (AWPA) sets forth guidelines for pressure treating based on factors such as wood species, preservative type, and end use. These guidelines help ensure that treated wood performs as expected when exposed to harsh conditions. However, they also highlight that not all wood needs to be treated, and floor joists may not always fall into the 'must be treated' category.

Preservative Types

Wood preservatives come in various formulations, with the most common being chromated copper arsenate (CCA), alkaline copper quaternary (ACQ), and copper azole. Each has its own unique properties, and their use is typically prescribed by industry standards like the AWPA.

the instructions for how to install and use floor joists
the instructions for how to install and use floor joists
stacked wooden logs with the words what about 2x6 deck joists?
stacked wooden logs with the words what about 2x6 deck joists?
Building Code for Sistering Joists
Building Code for Sistering Joists

For example, ACQ and CCA are commonly used for outdoor applications where wood is continually exposed to moisture and harsh weather conditions. Copper azole, on the other hand, is often used indoors due to its low toxicity and odor profile.

Moisture-Resistant Joist Species

Not all woods are equally susceptible to decay. Some species, such as cedar, redwood, and certain treated plywoods like plytanium, possess natural rot resistance. In these cases, pressure treating may not be necessary, provided that other safeguards, like keeping the wood dry and preventing contact with the ground, are observed.

AD

Additionally, some regional building codes may require pressure treating only if the floor joists are in continuous contact with the ground or exposed to excessive moisture. It's crucial to check local codes and consult with a professional when making these decisions.

Damp Problems and Damaged Joists: Restoring Integrity to a Rotten Floor
Damp Problems and Damaged Joists: Restoring Integrity to a Rotten Floor
How To Prevent Deck Joists From Rotting(15 Ways) - Decks by E3
How To Prevent Deck Joists From Rotting(15 Ways) - Decks by E3
How far apart should deck joists be spaced?
How far apart should deck joists be spaced?
Can You Use Pressure-Treated Wood Indoors Safely?
Can You Use Pressure-Treated Wood Indoors Safely?
Reinforcing Floor Joists - Pro Tips
Reinforcing Floor Joists - Pro Tips
Sagging Floor Joists: How to Fix Them - MellowPine
Sagging Floor Joists: How to Fix Them - MellowPine

Industry Standards and Best Practices

To ensure the longevity and safety of your home, it's essential to adhere to established industry standards and best practices. The International Residential Code (IRC), a widely accepted building standard in the U.S., offers guidance on floor joist construction, including recommendations for pressure treatment.

According to the IRC, floor joists placed directly on or near the ground should be pressure treated, and those above the ground should not. However, this is a general guideline, and specific requirements may vary based on local conditions and codes. Always consult with a local building inspector before starting any major project.

AD

Garage and Basement Joists

Garage and basement floor joists are particularly crucial to consider when thinking about pressure treating. Since these areas are often exposed to increased moisture and humidity, preventive measures like pressure treating can significantly prolong the lifespan of the wood.

Engineered Floor Joists vs 2×10 Lumber: Compared
Engineered Floor Joists vs 2×10 Lumber: Compared

Moreover, basement floor joists may be susceptible to termite infestation, making pressure treatment with an insecticide-laced preservative a wise choice. However, pressure treating isn't the only solution. Proper ventilation, moisture management, and the use of resistant wood species can also enhance durability.

When to Consider Alternative Solutions

In some cases, the costs and benefits of pressure treating may not align. For interior floor joists above ground, waterproofing and moisture control might be enough to safeguard the wood from rot and decay. Similarly, using naturally decay-resistant woods or metal joists can obviate the need for pressure treating.

AD

Furthermore, pressure treating may not always be possible or economically viable. If the joists are already in place, removing and treating them can be prohibitively labor-intensive and costly. In such cases, preventive maintenance and regular inspections can help extend the life of the joists without having to undergo the pressure treatment process.

In conclusion, the decision to pressure treat floor joists depends on various factors, including regional climate, building codes, and the specific application of the joists. While pressure treating can provide an added layer of protection, it's not always the silver bullet. Always consult with a local professional and consider all available options when planning your project. After all, your home's foundation deserves the best protection available.

AD