soundbar vs surround sound 2018

Soundbar vs Surround Sound 2018: Which Home Theater System Wins?

By Melissa Jones
AD

In the ever-evolving landscape of home audio, two prominent contenders have emerged as the go-to solutions for enhanced sound experience: the soundbar and the surround sound system. Both have their unique merits and shortcomings, catering to different needs and preferences. As we step into 2018, let's take a comprehensive look at these two powerhouses to help you make an informed decision.

Before delving into the specifics, it's essential to understand the primary difference between the two. A soundbar, as the name suggests, is a long, single-unit-speaker that typically rests in front of your television, while a surround sound system comprises multiple speakers placed around the room to create an immersive, 360-degree acoustic environment.

Soundbar Systems

Soundbars have gained significant traction in recent years due to their simplicity, affordability, and aesthetically pleasing design. They're especially appealing to consumers who prioritize minimalist setups and seamless integration with their smart home devices.

AD
Soundbar vs Surround Sound: Which Is Better For You?
Soundbar vs Surround Sound: Which Is Better For You?
Soundbar Or Surround Sound? The Honest Decision Chart 🔊
Soundbar Or Surround Sound? The Honest Decision Chart 🔊
Soundbar VS Surround Sound System
Soundbar VS Surround Sound System

Despite their single-unit nature, modern soundbars are equipped with advanced technologies like Dolby Digital andorr DTS:X to deliver an impressive soundstage. They also come in various configurations, from basic 2.1 channels to more advanced 5.1 and even 7.1 setups, with additional dedicated subwoofers and satellite speakers.

Pros of Soundbar Systems

Soundbars are renowned for their ease of installation. With a single chord to plug in and perhaps a couple of satellite speakers to place, you're ready to go in no time. They also tend to be more affordable than their surround sound counterparts, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious audiophiles. Additionally, they're less intrusive in terms of space, with no speakers dangling from your ceiling or tucked into corners.

how to choose a sound bar for your TV
how to choose a sound bar for your TV
Soundbars vs Surround Sound Systems (March 2026) Complete Comparison Guide - VVN News
Soundbars vs Surround Sound Systems (March 2026) Complete Comparison Guide - VVN News
Soundbar vs Speakers - Which One is Best For Your Home?
Soundbar vs Speakers - Which One is Best For Your Home?

Many soundbars now come with built-in Bluetooth or Wi-Fi connectivity, allowing for wireless streaming from your smartphone or other devices. Furthermore, high-end models often boast advanced features like voice control and AI integration, offering seamless interaction with your digital assistants.

Cons of Soundbar Systems

While soundbars have come a long way, they still can't match the immersive, theater-like experience of a dedicated surround sound system. Due to their placement in front of you, they lack the depth and spatial surround that a full 5.1 or 7.1 setup can deliver. However, this gap is closing rapidly with the introduction of soundbars equipped with upward-firing drivers that reflect sound off your ceiling, adding a vertical dimension to the soundstage.

AD

Moreover, while some soundbars aim to mimic surround sound by projecting audio around the room, they often fall short of replicating the true-to-life sound experience that dedicated rear speakers can provide. Lastly, withinely soundbars, you're limited to the number of channels (or speakers) you can add, whereas true 7.1 surround systems offer greater flexibility and scalability.

Tower Speakers Vs. Soundbar For Home Theater
Tower Speakers Vs. Soundbar For Home Theater
Soundbar VS Surround Sound
Soundbar VS Surround Sound
Sound bars buying guide
Sound bars buying guide
2.1 vs 5.1 Soundbar - What’s the difference?
2.1 vs 5.1 Soundbar - What’s the difference?
Can You Mount a Soundbar Above The TV?
Can You Mount a Soundbar Above The TV?
How to Understand Surround Sound Systems for Beginners
How to Understand Surround Sound Systems for Beginners

Surround Sound Systems

Surround sound systems have long been the gold standard for home theaters, offering an unparalleled audio experience that really places you in the middle of the action. They're particularly favored by cinephiles who value the authenticity of a movie theater sound experience in the comfort of their own home.

Traditional surround sound systems typically consist of a front and center channel, two side speakers, two rear speakers, and a dedicated subwoofer for low-frequency effects. Some high-end systems may also include height channels for a multidimensional soundstage.

AD

Pros of Surround Sound Systems

The most obvious advantage of a surround sound system is the truly immerse, 360-degree audio experience it provides. This is achieved by placing speakers around your listening position, creating a sense of presence that's unmatched by any other setup. Dialogue is crystal clear, while special effects and ambient sounds envelop you, drawing you into the content you're watching or listening to.

TV Speakers Are ON But Not The Surround Sound
TV Speakers Are ON But Not The Surround Sound

Another significant benefit is the scalability of surround sound systems. You can start with a basic 5.1 setup and gradually add more speakers, like a couple of height channels or even an additional subwoofer for enhanced bass, to build an expansive 7.2.4 system. This adaptability allows your system to grow with your evolving audio needs and preferences.

Cons of Surround Sound Systems

The primary drawback of a surround sound system is its complexity in terms of installation and setup. With multiple speakers scattered around the room, finding the optimal placement for each can be a headache, not to mention the wiring and amplifier configuration required. This intricacy can also make it a more expensive proposition, with components ranging from moderately priced to eye-wateringly luxurious.

AD

Furthermore, while soundbars are largely self-contained, a surround sound system demands a dedicated AV receiver, which serves as the brain of the operation, decoding audio formats and amplifying the signal to each speaker. Space constraints can also be an issue, as configuring an optimal setup requires careful planning and sometimes creative placement of speakers.

Ultimately, the choice between a soundbar and a surround sound system comes down to your personal preferences, budget, and the specific needs of your space. If you value simplicity, aesthetics, and seamless integration with your smart home devices, a soundbar might be your best bet. Conversely, if you yearn for a truly immersive, theater-like experience and are willing to invest time and effort into setting up a robust system, a surround sound system may be the way to go. Regardless of your decision, 2018 offers a wealth of fantastic options to elevate your home audio experience.

AD