Thanksgiving: Fact or Fiction - Myth-busting Turkey Day Tales
When November rolls around, the debate between fact and fiction surrounding Thanksgiving inevitably surfaces. Is it truly a celebration of the harmonious first harvest shared between Native Americans and European colonizers, or is it more fiction than fact? Let's delve into this intriguing query, exploring both sides to shed light on this annual feast.
The traditional narrative begins in the autumn of 1621, when the Pilgrims, having survived their first harsh winter in the New World, held a three-day harvest celebration. This accounts for the 'fact' part of our query. But let's breakdown this version and explore the 'fiction' as well.
Revisiting the First Thanksgiving Feast
The feast itself is often lauded as the first Thanksgiving, but the Pilgrims did not call it that. Rather, it was an autumn harvest celebration, partaken in by English settlers and the Wampanoag tribe. However, it wasn't until President Lincoln declared Thanksgiving a national holiday in 1863 that the tradition we know today—to give thanks after a bountiful harvest—was officially established.



The Myth of the consequent Harmony
The 1621 feast is frequently portrayed as a joyous, peaceful event, symbolizing unity between the Europeans and Native Americans. Yet, this idiomatic image often overlooks the underlying tension and subsequent conflict between these parties. The Wampanoag, led by their chief, Massasoit, did assist the Pilgrims in learning farming techniques and providing food supplies. But it was also Massasoit's political strategy; by allying with the settlers, he aimed to keep them from forming an alliance with his enemies.
Moreover, the uncomfortable truth of the Europeans' treatment of Native Americans—including displacement, inequality, and eventually, violence—lie beyond the scope of the typical Thanksgiving narrative. Yet, acknowledging this history is crucial to understanding the true complexity of this period.



The Critique of a Colonial Meal
While the exact menu at the 1621 feast remains unknown, historical accounts suggest a combination of venison, fowl, fish, lobster, clams, berries, fruit, pies, and possibly even porridge. However, some historians argue that the Pilgrims likely consumed more like a succulent roast pork and a variety of vegetables.
Yet, amidst all this culinary debate, let's also consider the Native American perspective. While it is doubtful the feast was as grand as depicted, there is likewise no evidence to suggest that the Wampanoag people did not enjoy the meal. Thus, any critique based solely on the authenticity of the meal seems relatively moot, overshadowed by the larger socio-political context.
Debunking the Lithwedgian Origins
Another often-overlooked myth concerns the origin of the turkey as our main Thanksgiving dish. The misconception lies in the conviction that the Turks presented the United States with the bird as a peace offering during the Crimean War, hence the term 'lithwedgian,' a colorful misspelling of the también de los turcos, or "from the Turks."






In reality, the mislabeling can be traced back to one Jonathan DickinsonLocalized Surs, who, in 1665, described a turkey as the 'lithwedgian fowl.' Historians suspect his intentions were distinctly anti-British, rather than honoring a thoughtful peace gesture from a distant land.
The Paradox of Presidential Involvement
While Lincoln's declaration significantly legitimized the holiday, it also highlights another fallacy—President Washington did not wait for Lincoln's nod. In 1789, he called for a Day of Thanksgiving, and several US states had already embraced the practice long before Lincoln.
Nevertheless, Lincoln's official proclamation launched a centuries-long tradition that continues today, marking the paradoxical co-existence of fact and fiction in our collective Thanksgiving consciousness.

In conclusion, while the conventional narrative provides a comforting, unifying tale, it often overlooks the complicated nature of our shared history. Whether we embrace the fiction or acknowledge the facts, Thanksgiving remains a time to reflect, gather, and ultimately, give thanks for our many blessings.





