Thuja Plicata vs Thuja Occidentalis: A Comparative Guide
Thuja plicata and Thuja occidentalis, both members of the Cupressaceae family, are coniferous evergreens commonly known as Western Red Cedar and Eastern White Cedar respectively. These two species, while sharing some similarities, exhibit distinct differences in terms of their origin, appearance, fragrance, uses, and maintenance requirements. Let's dive into a detailed comparison to help you understand these two impressive evergreens better.
Western Red Cedar (Thuja plicata) hails from the Pacific Northwest, thriving in the cool, moist climates of this region, while Eastern White Cedar (Thuja occidentalis) is native to Eastern United States and Southern Canada, preferring temperate climates. Both species are popular ornamental plants, but they have diverse applications and care needs.
Appearance and Fragrance
The most striking difference between these two species lies in their appearance. Thuja plicata, as its name suggests, is more arborescent, growing into a tall, majestic tree with dense, dark green foliage. It often reaches heights of 100 feet or more in its native habitat. In contrast, Thuja occidentalis is typically smaller and more shrubby, growing between 30 to 50 feet high, with lighter green, more delicate foliage.

![Platycladus orientalis (L.) Franco [ Biota orientalis (L.) Endl.]](https://i.pinimg.com/736x/52/9b/6d/529b6d4c3b72f81efb32a7ca409a997a.jpg)

Another notable difference is their scent. Western Red Cedar has a strong, distinct, and pleasant fragrance, while Eastern White Cedar has a subtler, less noticeable scent. This is mainly due to the differences in the composition of their essential oils.
Needles and Shape
The needles of Western Red Cedar are narrower, sharper, and more rigid, resembling small syringe-like structures. They grow in a spiral arrangement on the branch, providing excellent insulation and reducing wind resistance. Eastern White Cedar, on the other hand, has broader, more flexible needles that are scale-like and grow densely along the branches, creating a flat, fan-like appearance.



The shape of the plants themselves also varies. Thuja plicata often has a single trunk with spreading branches, resembling a pyramid when young and more of an oval shape as it matures. Thuja occidentalis is more often multi-stemmed or shrubby, with a rounded, often irregular shape.
Wood and Longevity
Western Red Cedar's wood is prized for its durability, resistance to rot and insects, and attractive grain. It's widely used for outdoor structures like decks, fences, and roofing. Eastern White Cedar also has durable wood, but it's not as robust or lasting as that of its Western cousin. It's typically used for indoor and outdoor projects where longevity is not as critical.
Both species are long-lived, with Thuja occidentalis living for over 300 years in optimal conditions, and Thuja plicata potentially living for even longer due to its robust constitution and resistance to environmental stressors.






Cultivation and Care
The two species have different cultivation and care requirements, which can influence their suitability for a given landscape. Western Red Cedar is more demanding, requiring a constantly moist, acidic soil and consistent shade to replicate its native habitat. It's also slower-growing compared to Eastern White Cedar.
Eastern White Cedar, being more adaptable, can tolerate a wider range of soil types, exposure to sunlight, and moisture levels. It's also faster-growing, which makes it an excellent choice for quick hedges and screens. However, it's less tolerant of cold, windy, or dry conditions compared to Thuja plicata.
Pest and Disease Resistance
Both species are quite disease and pest-resistant, but they have different susceptibility to specific issues. Thuja plicata is more resistant to bagworms, while Thuja occidentalis can be more prone to issues like cedar-apple rust and powdery mildew.

Interestingly, both species are hosts to the beneficial predator insect, the tent caterpillar (Malacosoma disstria). The caterpillars feed on the foliage, providing a food source for birds and other predators. This is a harmonious relationship that shows the interconnectedness of these evergreens within their ecosystems.
Uses in Landscaping
Thanks to their distinct appearances and growth habits, these two species have diverse applications in landscaping. Thuja plicata, with its potential to grow into a tall, impressive tree, is often used as an accent or specimen tree. Its dense foliage and strong fragrance make it a popular choice for windbreaks and privacy screens.
Thuja occidentalis, with its smaller size and quicker growth rate, is typically used as a hedge plant, windbreak, or specimen shrub. Its more open growth habit and lighter green foliage can provide filtered shade, making it an excellent choice for underplanting certain trees or in combination with other shrubs.
In conclusion, when considering Thuja plicata (Western Red Cedar) and Thuja occidentalis (Eastern White Cedar) for your landscape, it's essential to understand their unique characteristics, needs, and uses. Both species bring valuable assets to the garden, adding structure, beauty, and fragrance. By selecting the right species for your site conditions and desired use, you can ensure years of enjoyment from these wonderful evergreens.





