what burns more calories swimming or running

Swimming or Running: Which Burns More Calories?

By Joshua Brown
AD

When it comes to burning calories, two popular forms of exercise that often spark debate are swimming and running. Both activities offer excellent cardiovascular workouts and have distinct benefits, but which one comes out on top in terms of calorie burning? The answer might surprise you, as it largely depends on various factors.

Before we dive into the details, let's first understand the basics of calorie burning. Calories burned during exercise are primarily determined by your weight, the intensity of the activity, and the duration you engage in it. A pound of body fat is roughly equivalent to 3,500 calories, making it a useful benchmark for understanding weight loss.

Calories Burned per Minute

The rate at which you burn calories can be measured in calories per minute (cal/min). This metric is helpful for comparing different exercises, as it's independent of the duration of the activity. According to Healthline, a 155-pound person can expect to burn approximately:

AD
the calories burned swimming chart
the calories burned swimming chart
How Many Calories Do You Burn Swimming for 30 Minutes?
How Many Calories Do You Burn Swimming for 30 Minutes?
Swimming vs Running: Which Is Better for Your Body? 🏊‍♂️🏃‍♂️
Swimming vs Running: Which Is Better for Your Body? 🏊‍♂️🏃‍♂️
  • 12-14 calories per minute running at a pace of 5 miles per hour (mph),
  • 10-12 calories per minute swimming at a moderate pace,

However, these are just averages, and individual results may vary significantly based on factors such as age, sex, fitness level, and body type.

Running: Calorie Burning Factors

Several factors influence the number of calories burned while running:

5 Ways To Burn More Calories When You Swim
5 Ways To Burn More Calories When You Swim
How Many Calories Does Swimming Burn?
How Many Calories Does Swimming Burn?
This 30-Minute Showdown Reveals Whether Swimming or Running Burns More Calories, Builds More Muscle
This 30-Minute Showdown Reveals Whether Swimming or Running Burns More Calories, Builds More Muscle
  • Speed: Faster running promotes greater calorie burn. A 180-pound person running at 6 mph can expect to burn around 17 calories per minute, compared to just 8 calories per minute at a leisurely pace of 2 mph.
  • Terrain and Weather: Running uphill or against wind resistance can increase calorie expenditure compared to running on a flat surface or in calm conditions.
  • Injury Risk: High-impact running can stress joints and increase the risk of injuries over time, especially for beginners or those with prior injuries.

Swimming: Calorie Burning Factors

Swimming also has unique factors affecting calorie burn:

  • Intensity: Vigorous swimming (e.g., competitive or high-intensity laps) can burn more calories than moderate swimming. A 180-pound person can expect to burn around 15 calories per minute with vigorous swimming.
  • Hydrodynamics: Swimming's low-impact nature reduces stress on joints while still providing a challenging workout. However, poor technique can increase drag and decrease calorie burn.
  • Environmental Factors: Swimming in cold water can slightly increase calorie burn due to shivering, which uses energy. Additionally, swimming against a current can boost calorie expenditure.

Total Calories Burned: Running vs. Swimming

To compare the total calories burned between running and swimming, let's consider a 30-minute session for both exercises at moderate intensities:

AD
  • Running at 5 mph for 30 minutes would burn approximately 360-420 calories (based on the 12-14 cal/min average).
  • Swimming at a moderate pace for 30 minutes would burn around 300-360 calories (based on the 10-12 cal/min average).

Based on these averages, running appears to burn more calories than swimming for a 30-minute, moderate-intensity session. However, it's essential to consider that swimming typically engages more muscles and can provide a more balanced workout, especially for those with joint issues or injuries.

Energy use swim run cycling
Energy use swim run cycling
two pictures, one showing a woman swimming and the other shows a man running
two pictures, one showing a woman swimming and the other shows a man running
a woman swimming under water with the words how many calories does swimming burn?
a woman swimming under water with the words how many calories does swimming burn?
Highest Calorie Burn in One Hour 🔥 Top Exercises Ranked
Highest Calorie Burn in One Hour 🔥 Top Exercises Ranked
How many calories do you burn with Swimming? - Online Calculator!
How many calories do you burn with Swimming? - Online Calculator!
a nutrition label showing the calories burned per 1 hour
a nutrition label showing the calories burned per 1 hour

Muscle Engaged and Workout Variety

The number of calories burned is only one aspect to consider when choosing between swimming and running. Swimming engages more muscles than running, making it an efficient full-body workout. Additionally, swimming is gentler on joints, reducing the risk of injuries common to runners. On the other hand, running provides variety and versatility, allowing for easy outdoor exploration and social running events.

Ultimately, the best exercise is the one that you enjoy and can maintain as a long-term habit. Both swimming and running offer excellent cardio workouts and can be integrated into a healthy lifestyle. To maximize calorie burning and maintain a well-rounded fitness routine, consider incorporating both activities into your exercise regimen, along with strength training and restorative exercises like yoga or stretching.

AD
AD