what deicer is safe for concrete

Safe Deicers for Concrete: Protect Your Driveway & Sidewalks

By Hannah Jones
AD

When winter arrives, snow and ice can make walking surfaces slippery and dangerous. To maintain safety, deicers are used to melt ice and snow, but not all deicers are safe for concrete. Knowing which deicers are safe and which to avoid can help protect your concrete and the environment.

The two primary types of deicers are chloride-based and non-chloride-based. Chloride-based deicers generally offer better melting at lower temperatures, but they can be harmful to concrete and the environment.

Chloride-Based Deicers

Chloride-based deicers, such as salt (sodium chloride) and calcium chloride, provide excellent ice-melt performance. However, they can be quite damaging to concrete. When water evaporates, these deicers leave a residue that can seep into concrete, causing it to crack and crumble over time.

AD
Protecting Your Driveway Concrete From Winter Ice
Protecting Your Driveway Concrete From Winter Ice
Everyday - 🚶‍♂️❄️ Protect your walkways — and your concrete! Salt isn’t the only answer. This DIY sidewalk de-icer melts ice without damaging concrete, plants, or pets 🐾 A safer, smarter winter solution you’ll want to save 📌 #WinterSafety #DIYHacks #HomeMaintenance #EcoFriendlyLiving #WinterTips #PetSafe #SmartHome | Facebook
Everyday - 🚶‍♂️❄️ Protect your walkways — and your concrete! Salt isn’t the only answer. This DIY sidewalk de-icer melts ice without damaging concrete, plants, or pets 🐾 A safer, smarter winter solution you’ll want to save 📌 #WinterSafety #DIYHacks #HomeMaintenance #EcoFriendlyLiving #WinterTips #PetSafe #SmartHome | Facebook
a bottle of mouthwash next to a container of mouthwash
a bottle of mouthwash next to a container of mouthwash

Moreover, chloride-based deicers pose environmental hazards. They can pollute local waterways and harm wildlife. Overuse of these deicers can also lead to soil salinization, which can deplete the fertility of agricultural land and damage vegetation.

Salt (Sodium Chloride)

Salt is the most common deicer due to its low cost and effectiveness. It's typically used in large quantities on roads and sidewalks. However, its high concentration and repeated use can cause significant damage to concrete, especially in areas with heavy snowfall.

How To Melt Ice on Driveways, Sidewalks, and Entryways - Sensible Concrete
How To Melt Ice on Driveways, Sidewalks, and Entryways - Sensible Concrete
Snow Joe Enviro Blend 50lb Ice Melt - Green Deicer for Safe Patios
Snow Joe Enviro Blend 50lb Ice Melt - Green Deicer for Safe Patios
Ice Melt and Concrete
Ice Melt and Concrete

Furthermore, salt is corrosive to metals. It can cause damage to vehicles, metal railings, and other fixtures. It also presents a risk to pets and wildlife, as it can cause illness if ingested.

Calcium Chloride

Calcium chloride is another type of chloride-based deicer. It melts ice at lower temperatures than salt, making it more effective in cold climates. However, it's also damaging to concrete and poses environmental risks similar to those of salt.

AD

While calcium chloride may be less corrosive to metals than salt, it can still cause damage. It's also more expensive than salt, making it a less cost-effective option.

Pet Safe Snow Melter Ice Melt Deicer, Concrete Friendly Snow Melting Agent for Driveway Walkway Steps, Fast Acting Salt Free Formula for Home Outdoor Winter Use, Plastic Construction, Size:6.69" x 2.76" x 1.97", Multicolor
Pet Safe Snow Melter Ice Melt Deicer, Concrete Friendly Snow Melting Agent for Driveway Walkway Steps, Fast Acting Salt Free Formula for Home Outdoor Winter Use, Plastic Construction, Size:6.69" x 2.76" x 1.97", Multicolor
How to Make DIY Ice Melt Using Household Ingredients - Happy Mothering
How to Make DIY Ice Melt Using Household Ingredients - Happy Mothering
Snow Joe Eco-Safe Ice Melt – 50lb Green Deicer That Protects Concrete & Plants
Snow Joe Eco-Safe Ice Melt – 50lb Green Deicer That Protects Concrete & Plants
Chloride-Free De-Icer Pet Safe, Non-Toxic 4 Gallon
Chloride-Free De-Icer Pet Safe, Non-Toxic 4 Gallon
Homemade Deicer Products For Your Frozen Driveways
Homemade Deicer Products For Your Frozen Driveways
Daich Safe All-In-One General Purpose Concrete Cleaner & Etcher | Canadian Tire
Daich Safe All-In-One General Purpose Concrete Cleaner & Etcher | Canadian Tire

Non-Chloride-Based Deicers

Non-chloride-based deicers, such as magnesium chloride, potassium chloride, and sand, are safer for concrete and the environment. However, they may not work as well in extremely cold temperatures.

These deicers are usually more expensive than chlorine-based counterparts, but their long-term benefits can outweigh their initial cost. They are less toxic to vegetation and wildlife, and they don't contribute to soil salinization or car damage.

AD

Magnesium Chloride

Magnesium chloride is a more environmentally friendly alternative to sodium and calcium chloride. It's less damaging to concrete and presents less of a threat to pets and wildlife. However, it's more expensive and may not melt ice as efficiently at very low temperatures.

a poster with an image of someone pouring something into the water in front of them
a poster with an image of someone pouring something into the water in front of them

Magnesium chloride is often used in eco-friendly deicer blends or combined with other substances like sand to enhance traction and reduce the environmental impact.

Potassium Chloride

Potassium chloride is another safer deicer alternative. It's less damaging to concrete, soil, and vegetation than sodium chloride. It's also less harmful to pets and wildlife. However, it's typically more expensive and may not work as well as salt in extreme cold.

AD

Potassium chloride is often used in commercial or industrial settings where the cost can be justified by the long-term environmental benefits.

Sand

Sand is an inexpensive, pet-friendly, and environmentally safe alternative to chloride-based deicers. It provides traction on ice, making slippery surfaces safer to walk on. However, it doesn't melt ice and can be labor-intensive to apply.

Sand is often used in combination with other deicers to enhance traction and reduce the amount of chemical deicer needed. It's a good option for areas where pedestrian safety is a priority, such as school playgrounds or hospital entrances.

By using safe deicers and combining them with traction agents like sand, you can effectively manage winter sidewalk and walkway safety while protecting your concrete and the environment. Consider the benefits of non-chloride-based deicers, and weigh the initial costs against the long-term environmental and financial advantages. Remember, a little effort can go a long way in preserving our concrete infrastructure and protecting our natural world."

AD