what month was the first thanksgiving

November 1621: First Thanksgiving's Birth Month

By Joshua Walker
AD

The first Thanksgiving in American history is a topic shrouded in history and myth, marking a significant event in the country's early colonial past. But when did this historic gathering occur?

Situatedantwort in time, the first Thanksgiving is often associated with the Pilgrims, a group of English settlers who arrived on Plymouth Rock in 1620. However, the exact month of this celebration remains a subject of debate among historians.

Pinpointing the First Thanksgiving: Facts and Dates

Most history books and popular accounts place the first Thanksgiving in November, specifically in 1621. This is based on the accounts of Plymouth Colony governor William Bradford, who detailed a three-day feast held after the colony's first successful harvest. However, the actual timing can be somewhat ambiguous given that the colonial calendar at the time was different from ours today.

AD
two women dressed in native american clothing standing next to a table with the words, the first thanksgiving table
two women dressed in native american clothing standing next to a table with the words, the first thanksgiving table
The First Thanksgiving: What Really Happened
The First Thanksgiving: What Really Happened
The first thanksgiving 1621 painting
The first thanksgiving 1621 painting

Bradford wrote that the feast took place "in the harvest season, and continuing until we had all received our increases," which could denote late September or early October. However, due to later interpretations and the desire to align with the modern Thanksgiving tradition, it has become widely accepted and celebrated in November.

The Role of Harvest Festivals

The harvest season played a significant role in the timing of the first Thanksgiving. The Pilgrims, like many of their European contemporaries, celebrated harvest festivals and thanked God for a bountiful harvest. These celebrations, often observed in late October or early November, were a common occurrence in English villages and continued in the New World.

the first thanksgiving in america by j c lewis, framed painting on canvas with frame
the first thanksgiving in america by j c lewis, framed painting on canvas with frame
It wasn’t turkey: this was the main dish at the first Thanksgiving dinner in history
It wasn’t turkey: this was the main dish at the first Thanksgiving dinner in history
The Real History and Dark Truth of Thanksgiving in America
The Real History and Dark Truth of Thanksgiving in America

Given these traditions and the fact that the Pilgrims' first successful harvest took place in late September to early October, it's plausible that the first Thanksgiving occurred during this time. However, the exact month remains a matter of interpretation.

The Influence of Modern Tradition

A significant factor in why we celebrate Thanksgiving in November today is the influence of modern tradition. President Lincoln established Thanksgiving as an annual national holiday in 1863, choosing the fourth Thursday in November for the occasion. This helped solidify the date and month of the celebration in American culture.

AD

Since then, the significance of the specific month has shifted from its historical context to its cultural one. Today, November is more than just a month for Thanksgiving; it's a time for families to gather, express gratitude, and enjoy a hearty meal together.

a painting of people gathered around a table with food on it and pumpkins in the foreground
a painting of people gathered around a table with food on it and pumpkins in the foreground
an old painting of native americans and their dogs eating out of bowls on the ground
an old painting of native americans and their dogs eating out of bowls on the ground
an old painting shows people and dogs in the woods, with one woman serving food to another man
an old painting shows people and dogs in the woods, with one woman serving food to another man
What Is Thanksgiving Day?
What Is Thanksgiving Day?
The History of The First Thanksgiving Day
The History of The First Thanksgiving Day
The First Thanksgiving Story
The First Thanksgiving Story

The Difficulty of Precise Dating

The lack of a clear, universally accepted month for the first Thanksgiving is not an indication of historical inaccuracy, but rather a testament to the complexities of historical record-keeping and interpretation. The colonial calendar, the lack of precise chronological markers in Bradford's accounts, and the later shift to a national holiday all contribute to this ambiguity.

Ultimately, while the exact month of the first Thanksgiving might remain uncertain, the spirit of gratitude and unity it embodies lives on in the hearts of Americans today, making it a cherished annual tradition.

AD
Who Was at the First Thanksgiving? Fun Facts about Squanto
Who Was at the First Thanksgiving? Fun Facts about Squanto
AD