wirecutter best toaster

Wirecutter's Top Picks: Best Toasters in 2023

By Steven Brown
AD

Ever found yourself in a tussle with a toaster that can't keep up with your morning rush? We've all been there. That's why we've turned to Wirecutter, the product review site owned by The New York Times Company, to find the best toaster that balances speed, capacity, and style.

Wirecutter's top pick is the Cuisinart Countenance 4-Slice Toaster (CPT-122). But before diving into why, let's explore the factors that make a great toaster.

Key Features That Set the Best Toaster Apart

When Wirecutter began their search, they looked for toasters that could brown evenly, accommodate various bread types, and offer useful features like defrost and reheat settings.

AD
The Best Toaster Oven — NYT Wirecutter
The Best Toaster Oven — NYT Wirecutter
three toasters sitting on top of a white counter
three toasters sitting on top of a white counter
Best Toasters
Best Toasters

Even Browning and Bread Capacity

wirecutter found that the best toasters consistently browned bread evenly, from one side to the other and from top to bottom. They also looked for toasters that could accommodate bagels, Mueller buns, and different bread thicknesses.

Useful Features

Additional features like 'A Bit More' function, which adds a little more time to toasting, and wider slots for artisan bread, can escalate a toaster from good to great.

The Best Toaster
The Best Toaster
To Find the 5 Best Toasters, We Made Over 100 Pieces of Toast (Plus Bagels and Waffles)
To Find the 5 Best Toasters, We Made Over 100 Pieces of Toast (Plus Bagels and Waffles)
the best toasters on amazon are you ready to buy one or two for breakfast?
the best toasters on amazon are you ready to buy one or two for breakfast?

Why the Cuisinart Countenance 4-Slice Toaster Stood Out

The Cuisinart Countenance 4-Slice Toaster impressed Wirecutter with its consistent browning, compact footprint, and attractive design.

Consistent Browning and Even Heating

The Cuisinart can brown bread evenly, even when toasting two slices at once. Its even heat distribution ensures that your bread won't be pale in some spots and burnt in others.

AD

Compact and Stylish Design

Measuring just 11 by 7.9 by 7.1 inches, it's a good fit for small countertops. Its sleek design also doesn't look out of place on a countertop.

a silver toaster oven with the door open
a silver toaster oven with the door open
Best toasters to buy in 2026
Best toasters to buy in 2026
The Best Toasters for the Perfect Crispy Bite | Gear Patrol
The Best Toasters for the Perfect Crispy Bite | Gear Patrol
We Put 8 Toasters to the Test — Here’s the One Worth Buying
We Put 8 Toasters to the Test — Here’s the One Worth Buying
The Best Toaster
The Best Toaster
Best Toaster for Small Spaces and Minimalist Kitchens
Best Toaster for Small Spaces and Minimalist Kitchens

Wirecutter's thorough testing and comparison reassure us that the Cuisinart Countenance 4-Slice Toaster is indeed the best toaster for most people. So why not upgrade your breakfast game with a reliable and stylish toaster?

Is a Smart Toaster Worth It, Or Is It Overkill? I Tested One Against a Traditional Model to Find Out.
Is a Smart Toaster Worth It, Or Is It Overkill? I Tested One Against a Traditional Model to Find Out.
AD